After playing several games, for me humor kind of makes it. Serious themes are OK, but not nearly as appealing as stuff that leans pretty heavy on humor.
For that reason, the one I'd pick from the list is Wayne's World.
But I voted "other" because no matter what anyone else says, I always have a better idea. 

I'm thinking "Sanford & Son". Gotta love that theme song, and you could add a bunch of other blues and funk in the game. Lots of cheezy, worthless, funny junk to choose from for toys. Heart attack mode, steak dinner mode, ping pong at the lodge mode, Lamont takes the Soul Train mode, hide from Esther mode, Dozennaire mode, Strike it rich and lose it all multiball. You could add stuff from other era shows too, just because it would be cool to hear some Beverly Hillbillies stuff pop out from nowhere.

Click Here Dammit!

Oh yea...