Damn someone with zero feedback won it 

And I was going to wait until the auction finished and offer him $400 for the pin without his super rare overlay.  Surely due to its extreme rareness it must be immensly sort after by collectors all over they world and surely an overlay of that quality would have skyrocketed in value since he purchased it to at least ten times the value, making him one of the luckiest people in the world.

Damn you zero feedback bidder