I have purchased these NIB:

LOTR
Sopranos
Family Guy

I purchased these HUO (really low plays):

TSPP
SM

I have to say as exciting as it is to open a brand new pin I find it a little more enjoyable paying 800-900 less for a pin that's slightly used and looks new.  Even better I bought my SM HUO when everyone on RGP was saying the pin was junk because it had unfinished software.  I actually really enjoyed the software and now that they upgraded it it was a real steal 

On a side note, Nick, how did you tan your head while keeping your arms pale??