I was taken by Dialed In as well (I'd had a single came once at flip out before we had to go, and liked it then, so was keen to get some time on it). A really nice game, great shots, amazing animations, and probably one of the best light shows around.
Nug was even more impressed - talking about flipping a game or 2 to buy one!
I played Dialed in not long after it was released at the pacific pinball museum a couple of years ago, then had a bit more time on it at flipout last year. I really like the game, the lightshow is amazing, great to have a fresh unlicensed theme. It is definitely a game I would like to add to my collection. I have watched a few sales over the last year, they seem to take awhile to sell for some reason.
I think the theme kills it for most people, I personally like the theme.
And for whatever reason JJP games don't seem to hold their value, which is great if you are looking for one second hand.