A paint shop dealing in auto paints will be able to you out, they mix in a little bit of satin into normal clear, then it is just applied as per normal clear.  I have painted a few coats of normal clear then last coat with the satin mix.

I had a similar problem when spraying the volley, the finish was too reflective, so had to dull it down
http://aussiepinball.com/index.php?topic=6311.0